Consumer Behaviour toward Cosmetic Products: An
Integrative Review of Determinants, Digital Influence, and Purchase Intention
Reena Kumari
Himachal Pradesh University Business School,
Himachal Pradesh University, Shimla,
Himachal Pradesh, India,
&
Prof. Pawan Garga,
Himachal Pradesh University Business School,
Himachal Pradesh University, Shimla,
Himachal Pradesh, India.
Abstract: The cosmetic and
personal care segment has become rapidly expanding within the past several
years due to the increased awareness on beauty, changing lifestyles, increasing
disposable income, and the increasing popularity of digital marketing
platforms. Competitive nature of this market has made it more important that
academics and other individuals in the industry know how individuals behave
when purchasing cosmetics. The proposed research paper seeks to integrate the
available sources to single out the most relevant aspects in influencing
customer behavior within the cosmetic sector. In the study, the researcher uses
an integrative literature review approach to examine past research on product
qualities, pricing strategies, brand-specific issues, social effects,
psychological reasons, demographics and online interaction. The different
established theoretical models, such as the Theory of Planned Behavior, the
Stimulus–Organism Response model, brand equity theory, the perceived value
theory, the Theory of Consumption Values, and the self concept theory, provide
support to the review. The findings reveal that a number of related yet
independent factors influence the intention to purchase of an individual such
as the perception of the quality of the products, the level of trust in the
organization, the influence of social media, self-perception, and exposure to
online marketing. The conceptual framework presented in this paper is based on
the synthesis of existing researches and is used to demonstrate that variables
of products, aspects of brands, social influence and psychological factors are
used, and eventually lead to actual purchase behavior. The critical research
gaps also exist in the study, such as the necessity of more long-term research,
a more extensive focus on the developing countries, a more in-depth analysis of
male cosmetic consumers, and a better consideration of sustainability and
consumer behavior following the pandemic. The study makes a contribution to the
body of consumer behavior and provides practical suggestions to cosmetic
companies that operate in a more competitive and digitalized world.
Keywords:
consumer behavior, cosmetics, buying intention, digital influence, brand trust,
and marketing on social media.
1. Introduction
The global beauty and personal care market has
expanded exponentially in the past two decades. The beauty market has developed
significantly due to the rising awareness on the appearance of people, the
rapid urbanization, increasing disposable income, and changing lifestyles
(Euromonitor International, 2022). Cosmetics have ceased to be a luxury and not
only women, men use cosmetics on daily basis. Due to such rapid growth of the
industry, brands are competing against one another. This implies that researchers
and marketers should be aware of the way people act when purchasing cosmetics.
Consumer behavior is how individuals seek, select,
purchase, use and evaluate things and services to satisfy their needs and wants
(Solomon, 2018). It is affected by psychological, social, and personal factors
(Schiffman and Wisenblit, 2019). In the case of cosmetics, they do not simply
purchase them because they are effective, such as in terms of their prices or
quality, but because they make them feel and feel about them. According to Belk
(1988), products tend to fit in the extended self of the consumer hence such
that individuals use products to present themselves and what they like. The
cosmetics are usually associated with self-image, beauty and confidence which
complicates individuals in making choices as far as what to purchase in this
sector as compared to other sectors.
The Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) provides a
valuable platform on which to understand customer intention to purchase.
According to Ajzen (1991), the behavioral intention depends on three elements;
attitude towards the behavior, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral
control. People can be influenced by their perception of cosmetics, influence
by the peer or reference groups and perceived affordability of the product
greatly when it comes to their purchasing decision. The Stimulus-Organism-
Response (SOR) paradigm assumes that the external stimuli, such as advertising,
packaging, and online information, can affect the inner emotional reactions of
customers, which subsequently affect their buying behavior (Eroglu, Machleit
and Davis, 2001).
The past decades have seen significant influences of
digital transformation on the decision making process of people. Product
information, contact with brands, and conversations with fellow customers are
now among the finest social media sites (Kaplan and Haenlein, 2010). The
individual usually reads reviews, views beauty tutorials, and listens to the
influencers before they buy something. Electronic word-of-mouth (e-WOM) has
been identified to be an important factor in consumer attitudes and consumer
purchase behavior (Hennig-Thurau et al., 2004). It has been proven that
influencer marketing is very effective in increasing brand trust and purchase
intent in the beauty industry (Lou and Yuan, 2019). Consequently, online
communication has now become an extremely significant factor that influences
the way individuals purchase make-up.
Aspects related to the product are not yet less
significant in the definition of what people appreciate. Perceived quality is
considered to be an important factor in determining purchase intention
(Zeithaml, 1988). Their consumer behaviour has changed to be more mindful
towards the environment in recent years, which has led people to desire more
eco-friendly and sustainable beauty products (Amberg and Fogarassy, 2019). in
the cosmetics industry, people would take their time to consider what is in the
product, its safety, efficacy, smell, and packaging before they purchase it
(Kim and Chung, 2011). Consumers are increasingly worried about natural
ingredients, animal-free testing and environmentally friendly packaging.
The other key influence factor on the behaviour of
people is their perception of price. Pricing is often used by people to
determine the quality of something and the general level of value that it
possesses (Lichtenstein, Ridgway, and Netemeyer, 1993). It is believed by some
that the higher the price the higher the quality of a product and others more
price-sensitive and seek cheaper products. Such factors as brand also influence
purchasing. A good reputation will increase the chances of customers selecting
and remaining with a brand (Keller, 1993), whereas brand trust will lead to
customers being less insecure and more inclined to repurchase the same brand
again (Chaudhuri and Holbrook, 2001).
Other factors that influence the way individuals
purchase cosmetics include age, gender, income, and education (Schiffman and
Wisenblit, 2019). Digital trends, social media are more likely to influence
younger people and less likely to influence older people as the latter might be
interested in the effectiveness of a product and in its safety. These
variations demonstrate the relevance of splitting cosmetic consumers into
groups in terms of demographics.
Numerous studies have examined the factors which
influence the way individuals purchase cosmetics, yet the findings remain in
many locations, such as branding, sustainability, online marketing, and price
strategies. They therefore require an integrative approach that will help to
combine these data into a unified approach. Integrative literature reviews play
a vital role in the synthesis of the available information, identification of
gaps in research, and subsequent academic research (Torraco, 2005).
As a result, the main objective of the work is to
consolidate and critically analyze the available literature in order to
identify the key determinants that influence consumer behavior in respect to
cosmetic products. The discussion looks at product features, pricing
strategies, brand related, psychological effect, effect of digital marketing
and demographic attributes to provide a comprehensive understanding of the
consumer buying patterns in the cosmetic industry.
1.1Research
Problem Statement
Although research on the behavior of individuals in
the cosmetic industry has increasingly examined this behavior, much of what has
been done to date has focused on individual factors including product
attributes, brand image, pricing policies, or the impact of digital marketing
on any of them. Therefore, the literature remains undecided and has not yet
taken into consideration the general perspective whereby all these factors are
utilized as one. Moreover, the rapid digital transformation, the rise of social
media and increased consumer sensitivity to the sustainability factors have
altered the major patterns in cosmetic consumption dramatically. However,
little studies have synthetically brought together these developments under a
unified theoretical platform. As a result, this needs to be evaluated
rigorously in order to be able to summarize available literature and identify
the dominant influences on consumer behavior when it comes to cosmetic
products.
2. Review
of Literature
The global cosmetic and personal care industry has
expanded significantly in the last couple of years. The reason is that people
are becoming more sensitive to beauty, their life patterns are switching, their
disposable income increasingly increases, and internet-based marketing
platforms become more popular. As a result, the study of customer behavior with
respect to the use of cosmetic products has become a major point of research in
the field of marketing and consumer behavior. Scholars have examined many
factors influencing the buying behavior of customers, including product
attributes, the perception of price, brand-specific factors, social influence,
psychological intentions, and online engagement (Solomon, 2018; Schiffman and
Wisenblit, 2019). According to the literature, the consumption of cosmetics is
not a practical decision only but carries emotional and symbolic meanings as
well.
2.1Consumer
Behaviour in Consuming Cosmetics
Consumer behavior refers to how individuals search,
evaluate, purchase, and utilize services or products to satisfy their needs and
wants (Solomon, 2018). According to Schiffman and Wisenblit (2019), the
psychological dimension, the societal dimension, and the personal dimension are
all involved in the process of how individuals choose to purchase something. In
cosmetics, the general thought process is that the use of cosmetics is
associated with their self-esteem, beauty, and self-confidence. Belk (1988) introduced
a concept known as extended self, and it implies that people use objects to
express their individual personalities and individual values. The cosmetic
products can be characterized as the symbolic objects that could help to
express the social status, personality, and lifestyle decisions.
Previously conducted studies identified the
importance of attitudes and behavioral intentions in prompting consumer
decision-making. The Theory of Planned Behavior is a theory by Ajzen (1991),
which is based on the premise that attitudes, subjective standards and
perceived behavioral control contribute to the development of behavioral
intention. The positive perceptions of beauty products, social influence of
peers and affordability of the products play a significant role in influencing
the purchasing intentions in the context of cosmetic consumption (Kim and
Chung, 2011).
2.2 Product Attributes and Quality Perception
The product related attributes have been generally
embraced as significant determinant in consumer behavior in the cosmetics
industry. When purchasing cosmetics, people consider such aspects as the
quality of the product, the material; the safety of the ingredients, the smell,
the packaging, and its effectiveness (Zeithaml, 1988; Kim and Chung, 2011). It
has always been believed that think product quality is the large determinant of
customer satisfaction and their likelihood to make a purchase (Zeithaml, 1988).
Customers are also highly concerned about the safety
of products they purchase and the ingredients that are used to make it. This is
particularly the case of cosmetics which are applied directly on the skin. Kim
and Chung (2011) found out that the consumers are increasingly seeking cosmetic
products containing natural and organic ingredients because of the fears on the
health and environmental sustainability. Another similarity regarding the
consumption of cosmetics that was identified by Amberg and Fogarassy (2019) is
that individuals concerned with the environment are more likely to purchase cosmetics
that are produced in an environmentally friendly manner and are packaged in
packaging that can be reused.
Packaging of a product can also significantly
influence the thinking of people. Very competitive markets may make people
believe that an attractive packaging makes the product more valuable and make
the brand more visible (Rundh, 2016). Thus, product characteristics continue to
be the greatest factors that influence the decision of people when purchasing
cosmetics.
2.3 Price
Perception and Perceived Value.
The other important element that influences the
behaviour of individuals in the cosmetics market is the perception of prices.
Individuals usually consider the cost per unit of a commodity when determining
quality and the name of the brand (Lichtenstein, Ridgway, and Netemeyer, 1993).
Luxury cosmetic companies tend to sell at a higher price in order to
demonstrate that their products have a higher quality and can be sold to select
few individuals. Popular brands, on the other hand, target affordability to
target customers who are conscious about the price.
According to the theory of perceived value,
customers compare the perceived benefits and the perceived costs when they
value a product (Zeithaml, 1988). Customers will develop a favorable purchase
intention when they believe that the benefits of a cosmetic product will
outweigh the cost to them. Previous research shows that perceived value
significantly influences the customer happiness, brand loyalty and repurchase
behavior in cosmetic marketplaces (Sheth, Newman, and Gross, 1991).
2.4 Brand
Image, Brand Equity, and Brand Trust.
The brand consideration is very important in the
beauty industry in terms of individual decision making on what consumers
purchased. Brand image influences the way people consider the quality,
usefulness and value of a product (Keller, 1993). A strong brand marks in the
competitive markets are something where customers are more assured and more
appealing to use your brand rather than the others.
Brand trust has also been identified to be a
significant variable that contributes to consumer loyalty and repurchase.
Chaudhuri and Holbrook (2001) would argue that brand trust reduces the
perceived risk and increases consumer commitment to a brand. When purchasing
cosmetics, people prefer famous brands as these substances might irritate the
skin or be allergic.
It can also be influenced by the country of origin
in which a person will think of a cosmetic brand. According to Verlegh and
Steenkamp (1999), customers often associate a particular country with high
standards of cosmetic production and innovative technologies of beauty, which
improves the evaluation of the products and intentions to buy them.
2.5
Social Influence and Electronic Word-of-Mouth.
The role of social and cultural variables in the
purchase of cosmetics among people is enormous. According to Ajzen (1991),
reference group personal preferences such as relatives, friends, and peers can
play a great role in the consumer purchasing intentions. The views of people
concerning beauty products are mostly influenced by the comments of their
friends and their conversation with them.
The past few years have witnessed the transformation
of digital communication technologies in the way individuals obtain knowledge
about products and communicate with brands. Electronic word-of-mouth (e-WOM) is
a potent determinant of decision making among individuals. Hennig-Thurau et al.
(2004) found out that online reviews and consumer recommendations have a
significant influence on the consumer attitudes and consumer buying intentions.
The implication of digital communication on the use
of cosmetics has been enhanced by social media. According to Kaplan and
Haenlein (2010), social media allows individuals to share their opinions,
experiences and comments about the products in real time. The use of influencer
marketing has become very significant in the beauty industry. It was revealed
by Lou and Yuan (2019) that the credibility of an influencer and the honesty of
their message have a significant impact on the extent to which people trust a
firm and are willing to purchase a product offered by it.
2.6
Psychological and Demographic Factors.
Psychological factors also play an important role in
determining behavior regarding the consumption of cosmetics. Cosmetics are
often purchased by customers to express their uniqueness, enhance their
physical attractiveness, and enhance their self-esteem. The self-concept theory
states that individuals tend to prefer products that blend with their way of life
and identity (Sirgy, 1982). As such, cosmetics also play symbolic roles in
relation to practical roles.
The demographics also affect purchase behavior of
cosmetics. The age, gender, income, and educational attainment affect consumers
and their preferences and evaluation criteria towards products (Schiffman and
Wisenblit, 2019). Younger customers tend to be affected more by fashion trend,
social media posts, and celebrity endorsements (Djafarova and Rushworth, 2017).
Instead, elderly consumers often attach more importance to reliability of a
product, security, and effectiveness.
The recent researches have also centered on the
explosion of the male grooming industry. The shift in societal norms and
increased knowledge on personal grooming have led to the growth of men using
cosmetics in the world markets.
2.7
Research Gap
In spite of the recent enormous increase in the
literature on consumer behavior of cosmetic products, there are still several
significant gaps in the study.
To begin with, several of the previous studies have
considered particular factors, which affect cosmetic consumer behavior
individually, e.g. product features, brand image, price evaluation, or social
media pressure. Due to this fact, the literature under publication remains
haphazard and has no detailed framework to explain the interplay of these
factors in influencing the purchase intention and actual purchasing behavior
(Zeithaml, 1988; Keller, 1993; Hennig-Thurau et al., 2004).
Second, there is a considerable volume of up-to-date
literature conducted in developed countries such as US and Western Europe.
Consumer behavior could be different in a new market and developing economy due
to differences in culture, economic and social difference, thus, little
empirical research has been carried out in these markets (Verlegh &
Steenkamp, 1999). Thus, to understand the cosmetic consumer behavior in
developing countries, more context based studies are needed.
Third, most of the existing studies have
cross-sectional research designs that measure consumer attitudes and intentions
at a given time. Nevertheless, the changing lifestyle patterns, changing
standards of beauty, and the advancement of technology are influencing the
consumer behaviorin a dynamic and continuous manner. The longitudinal studies
that can examine the change in customer preferences over time remain scarce
(Sheth, 2020).
Fourth, academic literature has always been focused
on female consumer although the male grooming market has increased
exponentially. Consequently, little is known on what drives and habits of male
shoppers of cosmetics.
Finally, the ability of cosmetics business to offer
new research opportunities has been enabled by increasing consumer awareness of
ethical consumption and environmental sustainability. Nonetheless, instead of
examining the gap between sustainability targets and their real purchasing behavior,
most studies focus on consumer attitudes towards sustainable cosmetics as their
central aspect (White, Habib, and Hardisty, 2019).
A literature study is thus demanded to be
integrative in nature so that the existing studies can be combined and a comprehensive
framework can be established to explain the factors that influence consumer
behavior concerning cosmetic products. The present study addresses this gap by
integrating product related, brand related, social impact, psychological
motives as well as digital engagement into one conceptual model that can
explain cosmetic purchase intention and behavior.
3.
Research Methodology
This paper employs an integrated literature review
methodology in order to examine the factors that influence consumer behavior,
as pertains to cosmetic items. An integrative literature review is commonly
applied in social science research to gather the findings of different
theoretical and empirical research to come up with a comprehensive knowledge
about a given area of investigation (Torraco, 2005). This approach helps the
researcher to combine the results of the past research, identify patterns
within the literature, and develop conceptual frameworks that explain more
complex events.
The current research is aimed at reviewing the
existing scholarly literature associated with customer behaviour in the
cosmetic and personal care sectors. The appropriate information was collected
in the reputed academic databases such as Scopus-indexed publications, Google
Scholar, ScienceDirect, and SpringerLink. These are the sources that have been
selected due to the access to an excellent peer-reviewed research in the fields
of business studies, consumer behavior, and marketing.
The method used was the systematic search of
keywords in locating relevant studies. Relevant papers were identified with the
help of keywords related to the research topic. These keywords encompassed
consumer behavior related to cosmetics, intention to acquire cosmetics, consumer
behavior related to beauty products, brand trust on cosmetics, the role of
social media on cosmetic purchases as well as digital marketing in cosmetics
industry. The primary focus of the search process was on the scholarly
publications, which examine issues that influence consumer purchasing behavior
in the cosmetics industry.
The selected literature has been carefully studied
and analyzed where relevant researches were identified. The findings of the
previous literature were put in general thematic categories that reflected
significant aspects affecting cosmetic consumer behavior. Some of these
categories included product related factors, pricing attitudes, brand related
factors, social impact, psychological reasons, demographics and online
interaction. The ability to identify similar trends and patterns among the
factors that affect consumer buying behavior was simplified by categorizing the
literature into themes.
Famous theories of consumer behavior explaining the
process of decision making by consumers were used as additional guidelines to
the analysis. Some of these theoretical perspectives are the Theory of Planned
Behavior (Ajzen, 1991), Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR) model (Eroglu et al.,
2001), the perceived value theory (Zeithaml, 1988), the Theory of Consumption
Values (Sheth, Newman, and Gross, 1991), brand equity theory (Keller, 1993) and
self-concept theory (Sirgy, 1982). These theories could provide a theoretical
base to the interpretation of the influence of various variables on the desires
and behavior of consumers who purchase cosmetics.
This paper develops a conceptual model that defines
the relationship between product factors, variables touching on the brand,
social influence, and psychological motivation through integrating the available
literature to establish the key factors that drive the consumption of cosmetic
products. The framework continues to indicate the impact of these on the
purchase intentions of the consumers which in turn impacts on the actual
purchase behavior of consumers.
In general, the research can offer a detailed
understanding of the factors affecting cosmetic consumer behavior in the
contemporary markets through the synthesis of unrelated research results due to
integrative literature review methodology.
4. Theoretical
Framework
The theoretical basis of the consumer behavior
regarding the cosmetic products requires a solid foundation. Consumers in the
cosmetics market engage complex decisions regarding the psychological and
functional criteria. A multitude of famous theories of consumer and marketing
research explain how customers develop attitudes, purchase intentions, and
final purchase decisions. These theoretical positions illuminate psychological,
social, and value-oriented issues of cosmetic consumerism. By synthesising
different hypotheses, researchers may gain a profound insight into other
factors that may condition the purchase behaviour of cosmetics.
4.1
Theory of Planned Behavior
The Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) is one of the
most utilized models of consumer decision-making. Ajzen (1991) observed that
the three primary determinants of behavioral intention are attitude to the
behavior, subjective norms and what is perceived as behavioral control.
Subjective norms are viewed as a social pressure of important groups of
reference, attitude is a positive or a negative evaluation of a person to
participate in a behavior, and perceived behavioral control is the opinion of a
person on the ease or difficulty of the behavior.
In the case of cosmetic use, the customers usually
develop purchasing intentions when they believe that the cosmetics are able to
improve their appearance, beauty, and self-esteem. The adoption of certain
beauty products or brands and support of subjective norms by social influence
of friends, family members, and online influencers can be helpful. Similarly,
perceived behavioral control can also be affected by such factors as product
accessibility, availability, and pricing. The previous studies indicated that
the Theory of Planned Behavior would be applicable in predicting consumer
intentions with organic and personal care products such as cosmetics (Kim and
Chung, 2011).
4.2
Stimulus–Organism–Response (SOR) Model
Interaction The Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR)
Model is a theoretical framework designed to describe interactions between
stimuli and the organism (Lee, 2005). Interaction The
Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR) Model refers to a theoretical model that is
used to explain interactions involving stimuli and the organism (Lee, 2005).
Another important theoretical framework that can
help to explain consumer behavior is the Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR)
model. This method was initially employed in the field of environmental
psychology after which it was applied in marketing and retail environments.
Donovan and Rossiter (1982) are of the view that the external stimuli affect
the internal emotional state of an individual and in the process trigger
behavioral responses. Later studies extended the SOR model into the online
context, where digital stimuli were found to influence the emotions and
purchase intentions of the consumers (Eroglu et al., 2001).
Product packaging, brand communication, advertising
slogans, and influence endorsement, among other marketing elements, are all
stimuli in the cosmetics sector. These cues may prompt customers to purchase
cosmetics and invoke internal emotional responses such as enthusiasm, trust and
desire. The SOR model is particularly relevant in the digital era whereby the
content of the social media and marketing activities conducted online largely
influence the perception and consumer buying behavior.
4.3
Theory of Brand Equity and Brand Trust.
Brand-related theories are also important in
explaining customer behavior in the cosmetics industry. Brand equity is the
value that brand adds to a product as determined by the opinions of customers,
brand associations as well as brand awareness. Keller (1993) describes customer
based brand equity as the specific effects of brand awareness on consumer
response to marketing programs. Good brand awareness and positive brand
association can be used to increase purchase intention and perceived product
quality.
The brand trust is another factor that influences
customer loyalty and repeat business. Chaudhuri and Holbrook (2001) state that
brand trust and emotional attachment are some of the most important factors
that determine brand performance and long-term customer relationships. The
risks that could be felt by customers in the cosmetics industry include the
danger of product content or compatibility with the skin. Consequently, it
motivates the customers to choose the popular cosmetic items, in case they
trust the credible companies.
4.4
Theory of Perceived Value and Price Perception.
The perceived value theory holds that the consumers
analyze things by considering their perceived costs and benefits. According to
Zeithaml (1988), the perceived value of the product is the judgment that the
consumer makes on the overall utility of the product, its cost, and its
quality. In the case of cosmetics, the perceived benefits may be the fact that
one may look better, have healthier skin and feel more confident, while the
cost of a particular product and potential safety risks are considered to be the
main perceived costs.
Price perception also plays a role of a significant
factor in consumer purchasing decisions. Lichtenstein, Ridgway and Netemeyer
(1993) found out that price is often used by buyers as a measure of the value
and quality of a product. Whereas mass-market companies are interested in lower
prices to attract consumers with a low price elasticity, higher pricing
strategies are commonly employed by premium cosmetic companies to suggest high
quality and exclusiveness. Consequently, perception of value and price
perceptions are also important in affecting the decision of consumers to
purchase cosmetics.
4.5
Theory of Consumption Values.
The Theory of Consumption Values is another useful
method of explaining the consumer behavior. Sheth, Newman, and Gross (1991)
revealed that consumer decisions are influenced by a number of dimensions of
values, including functional, emotional, social, epistemic, and conditional
values. The cosmetics provide social value in terms of increased attractiveness
and social image, emotional value in terms of increased confidence and
satisfaction, and product performance in terms of functionality.
The Theory of Consumption Values is useful to
explain the choice of particular cosmetic brands or goods by consumers because
cosmetic consumption often includes both the logical assessment and the
emotional driving force. Customers can select cosmetics to have social and
symbolic uses along with utilitarian ones.
4.6
Self-Concept Theory
The self concept theory explains that customers
prefer products that are aligned to their central values and perceptions
concerning themselves. Sirgy (1982) reveals that the similarity in the image of
a product and the self concept of the consumer affects consumer behavior.
Individuals often fall into the trap of buying products that reflect the kind
of social identity, lifestyle, or personality they like.
Cosmetic products are highly linked to
self-expression and self-identity. The customers can choose cosmetic firms
according to their social status, lifestyle, or beauty level. This perspective
states the felicitous significance of cosmetics to shape the perception of
society and personal image.
5.
Major Determinants of Consumer Behaviour
The consumer behavior of cosmetic products is
influenced by different factors that are also interrelated. Previous research
found out that the characteristics of the products, price practices,
brand-based factors, social factors, psychological factors, demographic
factors, and online interactions influence consumer purchase decisions of
cosmetics. Collectively, these together affect buyer perceptions, intentions to
buy and actual buying.
5.1
Product-Related Factors
The features of a product play a critical role in
the decision made by the customers to buy products in the cosmetic industry. It
is well known that perceived product quality is one of the most appropriate
measures of customer satisfaction and purchase intention (Zeithaml, 1988).
Make-up which leads to recognizable, reliable, and long-lasting effects have
better chances to attract customers and encourage repeat buying.
Since cosmetics are deposited on to the skin, the
ingredient and safety of the product are highly important. Consumers are
increasingly aware of ingredient transparency and formulations of products when
purchasing cosmetics (Kim & Chung, 2011). The concerns about harmful
substances, allergies, and compatibility to the skin are also considered to
have significant influence on consumer decision-making.
Also, the packaging can significantly influence the
consumer perception of cosmetics. Attractive, innovative, and practical
packaging can help increase the appeal of a brand and enhance the value of a
product (Rundh, 2016). Moreover, consumers have become more interested in
organic, herbal, and environmentally friendly cosmetics with the increase in
environmental awareness. The popularity of products of natural ingredients,
without cruelty tests, and ecological packaging are gaining momentum
(Amberg&Fogarassy, 2019). These trends are among the overall trends in the
cosmetics industry of responsible and sustainable purchasing.
5.2 Price
and Value Perception
Price perception is also another important issue
that affects cosmetic buying behavior. Consumers often use price as a parameter
of a product and its price and quality (Lichtenstein et al., 1993). Although
mass-market brands help focus on cost and availability to reach more consumers,
more expensive price strategies are occasionally employed by premium cosmetic
companies to represent higher quality, exclusivity, and prestige.
Perceived value is also an important factor in
purchase intention since it is the trade off between perception of costs and
benefits (Zeithaml, 1988). The belief that the benefits of a cosmetic product
are more than the cost encourages the customer to purchase the product. Price
sensitivity on the other hand varies among the customer groups and more so in
accordance to the purchasing power and income levels. Thus, price perception
and perceived value in brand choice and product preference in the cosmetic
business is significantly affected.
5.3
Brand-Related Factors
Brand-related variables are significant in the
decision-making of customers in the cosmetics market. Product image plays a
major role in influencing consumer perception of the product in terms of
quality, consistency, and effectiveness (Keller, 1993). Great brands have a
great reputation and customers are more likely to buy a product.
Due to the potential risks with cosmetics, such as
skin irritation or allergic responses, brand credibility is critical indeed.
Consumers would purchase and repurchase products of a brand that they trust
(Chaudhuri and Holbrook, 2001). This trust is what enhances the long-term
consumer-brand associations and improves brand loyalty in the end (Oliver,
1999).
Besides, country-of-origin effect might affect the
buying behavior of cosmetic products. Customers often associate certain
countries with high standards of cosmetics and the latest trends in the beauty
technology, which positively influences the way consumers evaluate the products
and brands (Verlegh and Steenkamp, 1999).
5.4
Social and Cultural Influences.
The social and cultural variables are also important
in determining the cosmetic consumer behaviour. Friends, family and peer groups
often shape consumer opinion and preference concerning cosmetic products.
Behavioral intention models indicate that subjective norms can have a huge
impact on the purchase intention (Ajzen, 1991).
The use of cosmetics has experienced a major
influence in recent years by the social media. Electronic word-of-mouth (e-WOM)
online reviews and peer recommendations are also electronic word-of-mouth,
which affects consumer trust and purchasing decision dramatically
(Hennig-Thurau et al., 2004). Influencer marketing has been an important
marketing strategy within the cosmetics industry. Brand attitudes and purchase
intention can be significantly influenced by the influencers since consumers
often consider them as credible and familiar knowledge about a product (Lou and
Yuan, 2019).
These social factors contribute to the increase in
the necessity of cosmetic products, which contribute to the formation of the
modern aesthetic standards and customer expectations.
5.5
Psychological Factors
The psychological variables can be highly considered
as the explanations of consumer behavior in cosmetics industry. The purchase
intention can be strongly predicted by the attitude towards the cosmetic
products (Ajzen, 1991). Customers are more likely to purchase cosmetics in case
of their positive views concerning their effectiveness and benefits.
Motivation also plays a major role in the use of the
cosmetics. Many individuals apply cosmetics to enhance their confidence,
appearance and self esteem. Self-concept theory holds that individuals prefer
products that enhance their identities and self-concepts (Sirgy, 1982).
Consumer perception also determines the evaluation
of the product claims and marketing messages. Preconceived notions and previous
experience help people to comprehend the information about the product and
marketing. Also, the lifestyle factors strongly influence the amount of
cosmetics that individuals purchase. Consumers who are fashion conscious or
appearance oriented are generally high users of cosmetics.
5.6
Demographic Factors
Demographics also determine purchase behavior of
cosmetics. Since the younger customers are usually more susceptible to fashion
tendencies, endorsed celebrities and digital marketing strategies, age is a
major factor of product preference (Djafarova and Rushworth, 2017).
Gender also differs in terms of consumption habits
of cosmetics. Male grooming has been one of the markets that have grown
exponentially over the past few years, even though the historical understanding
of cosmetic use has been associated to female users. The purchasing power of
consumers of the expensive cosmetic brands is determined by their income level,
and their education level can play a role in their awareness of ingredients of
products and the rules of sustainability and safety. These demographic
characteristics determine the difference in the consumer segments preference of
the cosmetic products.
5.7
Digital Influence
Digital technologies have greatly influenced the
consumer behavior of the cosmetics industry. The Internet reviews and
electronic word-of-mouth have become an important source of product knowledge
and contribute to consumer trust and purchase intentions (Hennig-Thurau et al.,
2004).
Social media platforms such as YouTube and Instagram
have evolved to be useful marketing platforms in the cosmetics industry. Visual
content, product demonstrations, beauty hacks, and influencer partners can
largely affect consumer attitudes and perceptions towards a brand (Lou and
Yuan, 2019).
There has also been an increase in online cosmetic
purchases which are due to the growth of e-commerce due to its convenience, a
variety of products, and the capability of comparing prices between the
different brands. Quality of websites, online presentation of products and
online customer interaction can significantly contribute to consumer opinions
and consumer buying patterns (Eroglu et al., 2001).
6.
Conceptual Framework
Using the theoretical background and the material
investigated in the sections above, a conceptual framework is suggested to describe
consumer behaviour to cosmetic product. The proposed model uses social,
psychological, brand related, and product related variables as significant
independent variables which influence the intentions of customers to make
purchases. These purchase intentions result in actual purchasing behavior.
The framework is based on the Theory of Planned
Behavior, which argues that the behavioral intention is the strongest predictor
of actual behavior (Ajzen, 1991). This theory is based on the fact that the formulation
of intentions is determined by a set of consumer attitudes and social factors,
in addition to perception of control over purchasing behavior. Additionally,
both the internal consumer evaluation and external market pressure influence
purchase intention as postulated in the brand trust theory and the perceived
value theory (Chaudhuri and Holbrook, 2001; Zeithaml, 1988). Purchase intention
therefore, is an intervening factor in the proposed construct, which connects
the key elements that affect consumer behavior to actual buying behavior.
6.1
Independent Factors
6.1.1
Elements of the Product
Factors of product are important indicators of
consumer behavior when it comes to the cosmetics industry. Some of these
variables are perceived quality of the product, the type of ingredients used,
product safety, the design of the container, product innovation, and the
tendency towards use of organic or herbal cosmetics. In earlier studies, the
perceived quality and product value have been found to have a significant
impact on consumer rating and intended buying behavior (Zeithaml, 1988).
Increasing consumer health and safety information has further emphasized the
importance of ingredient transparency and product safety in the purchase
decisions of consumers of cosmetics.
6.1.2
Brand Factors
Some of the brand-related determinants include brand image, brand trust,
brand loyalty and the country of origin impression. What makes high brand
perception is that the consumer trusts more and makes the brand dependable
(Keller, 1993). Chaudhuri and Holbrook (2001) indicate that brand trust
minimizes the risk perception of a cosmetic product and increases the chances
of likelihood of a repeat purchase. These brand-related traits are important
determinants of intentions of customers to purchase cosmetics.
6.1.3
Social Influence
The social influence is used to describe the
influence of the social media contacts, peer groups, family members, and
influencer marketing on the customer behavior. Electronic word-of-mouth (e-WOM)
such as online reviews and recommendations have a significant impact on
consumer attitudes and their purchase decisions (Hennig-Thurau et al., 2004).
Customers also intend to buy cosmetics influenced by digital endorsements and
the influencer reputation, particularly young people (Lou and Yuan, 2019). The
contemporary digital settings have made social influence an important predictor
of cosmetic consumer behaviour.
6.1.4
Aspects of Psychology
Examples of psychological determinants
include consumer attitudes, perception, motivations, self-image, and lifestyle
orientation. According to Ajzen (1991), consumer perceptions towards a product
have a direct impact on the purchasing intentions. Moreover, the customers
often prefer the cosmetics that best match their personal identity and
self-concept (Sirgy, 1982). The behavioral motivation of consumption of
cosmetics is very strong based on the motivation to increase his/her
appearance, improve self-confidence and self-identity expression
6.2 Purchase Intention as an Intermediate Variable.
The buying intention of a consumer is a defined
intention that shows that the consumer is willing or ready to purchase a
cosmetic product. It is not a secret that the behavioral intention is a good
predictor of actual purchase behavior (Ajzen, 1991). Whenever customers develop
positive intentions influenced by positive product decisions, brand perception,
social influence, and psychological reasons, they will be more inclined to
proceed with the purchase decision. Consequently, purchase intention is an
interactive variable between the significant variables that affect customer
behavior and the purchase outcome.
6.3
Dependent Variable: Actual Purchase Behaviour
Actual purchase behaviour is the ultimate behaviour
to purchase cosmetic products. Though purchase intention can be said to be a
powerful predictor of behaviour; situational factors including availability of
the product, price fluctuation, promotion, and availability can be used to
determine the ultimate purchase decision. Moreover, technological advancements
and development of online shopping platforms have also influenced the
correlation between the purchase intention and the actual purchase behaviour.
According to the recent researches, it was found out that the purchasing
behaviour in cosmetic markets has been altered greatly due to the digital
accessibility and post-pandemic consumer behaviour (Sheth, 2020).
.6.4
Proposed Conceptual Framework
The conceptual model proposed in this study can be summarized as follows:
This conceptual model holds that purchase intentions
of the consumers are affected by numerous internal and external factors which
in turn have an impact on the actual cosmetic shopping behavior. The model
provides an in-depth concept of the understanding of factors that drive
consumer behavior within the cosmetics industry and it integrates significant
theoretical perspectives.
7.
Implications
The existing integrative study on consumer behavior
considering cosmetics has profound managerial and theoretical implication. This
research contributes to the academic literature and practice of management as
it integrates various determinants and theoretical perspectives. The findings
are useful to researchers, marketers and could be used by industry stakeholders
who would have a better insight on cosmetic consumer behavior.
7.1
Theoretical Implications
This research provides a lot of valuable contributions to the consumer behavior theory.
To explain cosmetic purchasing behavior, the paper initially integrates a number of theories including the Theory of Planned Behavior, brand equity theory, perceived value theory and self-concept theory into one conceptual model (Ajzen, 1991; Keller, 1993; Zeithaml, 1988; Sirgy, 1982). The proposed paradigm demonstrates the interplay of product-related, brand-related, social and psychological factors in determining the purchase intention and the eventual effect on actual purchase behavior, although some studies have often studied these theoretical concerns on an independent basis in the past.
Second, the study introduces new dimensions of conventional behavioral intention theories, such as the role of contemporary digital determinants, such as social media influence and electronic word-of-mouth influence. In present-day cosmetics marketing, where online marketing has a significant impact on consumer behavior and buying decisions, the combination of these conventional consumer behavior theories and digital marketing dynamics makes the theory more usable (Hennig-Thurau et al., 2004; Lou and Yuan, 2019).
Third, this review notes several research gaps in the literature, which include lack of longitudinal studies, scarcity of research in developing countries, the lack of male cosmetic users, and the need to conduct conduct studies that are sustainability-driven. Through highlighting these shortcomings, the work provides the necessary alternatives to future theorizing and empirical research.
In general, the proposed integrative framework contributes to a deeper insight into the consumer behavior of cosmetics by taking into account psychological, social, branding, and digital perspectives in one conceptual framework.
7.2.1
Strategic Implications for Cosmetic Companies
Product safety, transparency of ingredients, and
quality should be at the top priority list of cosmetic companies since these
factors influence the intentions of consumers to make purchases greatly. The
increasing awareness of the sustainability, health, and ethical consumption of
packaged goods, testing without animal subjects, or sourcing of ethical
ingredients also demand companies to invest in environmentally friendly
packages, animal testing, and sourcing of ethical ingredients.
Brand trust and image should be well handled in the
cosmetics industry. Good brand positioning will ensure that customers show
confidence and loyalty in the brand in the long run (Chaudhuri and Holbrook,
2001). In order to reduce the perceived risk and to boost the customer
confidence, organizations are encouraged to frequently communicate product reliability,
safety needs, and brand values.
7.2.2
Digital Marketing Focus
The digital-first marketing strategies used by
cosmetic companies are necessitated by the growing influence of social media
and the use of influencers. Online word-of-mouth has become an effective source
of product information and significantly influences the choice of customers to
purchase a product (Hennig-Thurau et al., 2004). Consequently, companies ought
to monitor and control social media communication, customer ratings, and reviews
very carefully.
Authenticity, openness, and trustworthiness are the
qualities a person should have since they play a major role in customer trust
and buy intention, which means that influencer marketing strategies must focus
on these aspects (Lou and Yuan, 2019). Encouraging user-generated content and
collaboration with decent beauty influencers can boost the brand awareness and
participation.
It is also necessary to improve e-commerce systems
and ensure that the customer purchasing behavior occurs after the transition of
purchase intents into the actual purchasing behavior.
7.2.3
Product Development Insights
The growing number of sustainable, organic, and herbal cosmetics supports a growing trend in the number of environmentally conscious and health sensitive consumers. As such, cosmetic companies must invest in research and development in order to come up with new formulae of their products, which comply with the ethical and sustainable production standards.
Further, a business can develop effective product positioning and segmentation strategies after understanding psychological motivators such as self image, lifestyle orientation and personal identity. The brands of cosmetics can meet the diverse preferences of modern customers by differentiating on the basis of value, high-end package design, and product personalization.
The research has valuable
recommendations in understanding consumer behavior about cosmetics besides the
enrichment of the theory. The paper uses various consumer behavior theories within
a unified structure that describes the patterns of cosmetic purchases in a
theoretical manner. The findings provide viable strategies in branding, online
advertising, sustainability, and innovation of products on a managerial
perspective. These data can help the cosmetic companies develop competitive
strategies in a market that is increasingly digitalized and
sustainability-oriented.
8.
Limitations of the Study
There are a number of limitations that can be
mentioned, although this study contains some interesting information on what
drives consumer behavior to purchase cosmetic products. To begin with, the
research does not rely on original empirical data but on already existing
research since it is founded on an integrated literature assessment. Hence, the
findings will depend on the level and quality of past studies.
Second, most of the literature used in the review
was the scholarly literature in English, and this could have restricted
accessibility to the pertinent researches in other languages. Third, much of
the past research is conducted in the developed economies, which might restrain
the extrapolation of the results to the new markets, despite the research being
a synthesis of the results across multiple geographical settings.
Besides, no empirical testing of the conceptual
framework presented in this study has been conducted. In order to assess the
proposed model and explore the relationship between the variables identified
and consumer buying behavior, the future studies should conduct quantitative or
mixed-method empirical studies.
Despite these limitations, the present research
possesses an extensive summary of the existing literature and a useful
theoretical framework that can be used to understand consumer behaviour with
respect to cosmetics.
Conclusion
Using the integrated information of the earlier
findings and applying all the relevant concepts, this integrative literature
review examined the most vital determinants of consumer behavior to the
cosmetic items. The review indicates that cosmetic purchasing behaviour is
intricate and influenced by multiple interconnected factors, such as
product-related attributes, price and perception of value, brand-related
factors, social impressions, psychological factors, demographic attributes, and
online presence. Combically, these factors influence the purchasing intentions
of the consumers that subsequently influence the purchase decision of the
consumers.
The outcome demonstrates that the quality of
products, their safety, ingredients, and packaging remain to have a significant
impact on the opinion of cosmetics consumers. Brand image, brand trust and
perceived value are also important in consumer confidence and long-term
loyalty. Social and digital aspects (e.g. online reviews, influencer marketing,
and electronic word-of-mouth) have significantly impacted modern cosmeteric
consumption. The psychological reasons, such as self-image, self-confidence,
and lifestyle orientation also play an essential role, proving an additional
role of cosmetics as the symbols of self-expressing along with being a useful
item.
The study makes a contribution to the body of
literature by synthesizing different findings together with a conceptual
framework that elucidates the effect of product variables, brand factors, social
influences, and psychological determinants on purchase intention and,
consequently, purchasing behavior. This paradigm offers a more holistic
understanding of the consumer behaviour in the cosmetic industry which is
becoming more digitized and cutthroat.
Overall, there are practical implications to the
cosmetic industries and useful academic reflections in the review. The need to
study developing economies, male customers, sustainability, and changing
post-pandemic cosmetic purchase behaviour are also mentioned in the future.
References
Ajzen,
I. (1991). The theory of planned behavior. Organizational Behavior and
Human Decision Processes, 50(2), 179–211.
Amberg,
N., &Fogarassy, C. (2019). Green consumer behavior in the cosmetics market.
Resources, 8(3), 137.
Belk,
R. W. (1988). Possessions and the extended self in consumer behavior. Journal
of Consumer Research, 15(2), 139–168.
Chaudhuri,
A., & Holbrook, M. B. (2001). The chain of effects from brand trust and
brand affect to brand performance: The role of brand loyalty. Journal of
Marketing, 65(2), 81–93.
Djafarova,
E., & Rushworth, C. (2017). Exploring the credibility of online
celebrities’ Instagram profiles in influencing the purchase decisions of young
female users. Computers in Human Behavior, 68, 1–7.
Donovan,
R. J., &Rossiter, J. R. (1982). Store atmosphere: An environmental
psychology approach. Journal of Retailing, 58(1), 34–57.
Eroglu,
S. A., Machleit, K. A., & Davis, L. M. (2001). Atmospheric qualities of
online retailing: A conceptual model and implications. Journal of Business
Research, 54(2), 177–184.
Euromonitor
International. (2022). Beauty and personal care market overview.
Euromonitor International.
Hennig-Thurau,
T., Gwinner, K. P., Walsh, G., &Gremler, D. D. (2004). Electronic word-of-mouth
via consumer opinion platforms: What motivates consumers to articulate
themselves on the internet? Journal of Interactive Marketing, 18(1),
38–52.
Kaplan,
A. M., &Haenlein, M. (2010). Users of the world, unite! The challenges and
opportunities of social media. Business Horizons, 53(1), 59–68.
Keller,
K. L. (1993). Conceptualizing, measuring, and managing customer-based brand
equity. Journal of Marketing, 57(1), 1–22.
Kim,
H. Y., & Chung, J. E. (2011). Consumer purchase intention for organic
personal care products. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 28(1), 40–47.
Lichtenstein,
D. R., Ridgway, N. M., &Netemeyer, R. G. (1993). Price perceptions and
consumer shopping behavior: A field study. Journal of Marketing Research,
30(2), 234–245.
Lou,
C., & Yuan, S. (2019). Influencer marketing: How message value and
credibility affect consumer trust and purchase intention. Journal of
Interactive Advertising, 19(1), 58–73.
Oliver,
R. L. (1999). Whence consumer loyalty? Journal of Marketing, 63(4),
33–44.
Rundh,
B. (2016). The role of packaging within marketing and value creation. British
Food Journal, 118(10), 2491–2511. https://doi.org/10.110
Schiffman,
L. G., &Wisenblit, J. (2019). Consumer behavior (12th ed.).
Pearson Education.
Sheth,
J. N. (2020). Impact of COVID-19 on consumer behavior: Will the old habits
return or die? Journal of Business Research, 117, 280–283.
Sheth,
J. N., Newman, B. I., & Gross, B. L. (1991). Why we buy what we buy: A
theory of consumption values. Journal of Business Research, 22(2),
159–170.
Sirgy,
M. J. (1982). Self-concept in consumer behavior: A critical review. Journal
of Consumer Research, 9(3), 287–300.
Solomon,
M. R. (2018). Consumer behavior: Buying, having, and being (12th ed.).
Pearson Education.
Torraco,
R. J. (2005). Writing integrative literature reviews: Guidelines and examples. Human
Resource Development Review, 4(3), 356–367.
Verlegh,
P. W. J., & Steenkamp, J. B. E. M. (1999). A review and meta-analysis of
country-of-origin research. Journal of Economic Psychology, 20(5),
521–546.
White,
K., Habib, R., &Hardisty, D. J. (2019). How to shift consumer behaviors to
be more sustainable: A literature review and guiding framework. Journal of
Marketing, 83(3), 22–49.
Zeithaml,
V. A. (1988). Consumer perceptions of price, quality, and value: A means–end
model and synthesis of evidence. Journal of Marketing, 52(3), 2–22.
Sirgy,
M. J. (1982). Self-concept in consumer behavior: A critical review. Journal
of Consumer Research, 9(3), 287–300.
Solomon,
M. R. (2018). Consumer behavior: Buying, having, and being (12th ed.).
Pearson Education.
Verlegh,
P. W. J., & Steenkamp, J. B. E. M. (1999). A review and meta-analysis of
country-of-origin research. Journal of Economic Psychology, 20(5),
521–546.
White,
K., Habib, R., &Hardisty, D. J. (2019). How to shift consumer behaviors to
be more sustainable: A literature review and guiding framework. Journal of
Marketing, 83(3), 22–49. Zeithaml, V. A. (1988).
Consumer
perceptions of price, quality, and value: A means–end model and synthesis of
evidence. Journal of Marketing, 52(3), 2–22.
